Munchausen
Syndrome by Proxy Case Studies #6
Insight into real-life cases of MSP. |
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. - With 200 hospitalizations and 40 surgeries in her 8
years, Jennifer Bush became a symbol of out-of-control health care costs, even earning a
visit with Hillary Rodham Clinton.
Now, authorities who received a tip say Kathy Bush made
her daughter sick by putting feces in her feeding tubes. She also is accused of persuading
doctors to perform unneeded surgeries on Jennifer.
"The allegations are that this is a case of 'Munchausen's
by proxy,' in which a parent intentionally induces or inflicts injury upon their child to
gain attention," says Broward County Assistant State Attorney Dennis Nicewander.
best forum http://azcustomerservices.co.uk/ uk supports
The girl was placed in state custody on Monday. On
Tuesday, a circuit judge ruled that she should remain there. Bush, 38, who had sought
publicity and donations for Jennifer, will answer charges April 29 of aggravated child
abuse and fraud for allegedly obtaining unnecessary medical services. Bush has said
Jennifer's medical bills cost $3 million.
Prosecutors say that during the solicitations, the Bushes
bought a $19,000 pool, two cars and a $25,000 motorcycle.
Bush and her lawyer vehemently deny that she made the
girl sick, categorizing the state's case as a "witch hunt." Her husband, Craig,
44, is not charged.
Jennifer has had her gall bladder, appendix and part of
an intestine removed, and prosecutors say doctors took her mother's diagnoses at face
value. Once a secretary to Jennifer's former pediatrician, Kathy Bush was fired in 1993
for stealing money, the arrest warrant says.
The Florida case spotlights a once obscure psychological
disorder that has spawned a TV movie, a mystery novel and more than 200 reports in medical
journals.
"We know it's not rare," says Oakland, Calif.,
psychiatrist Herbert Schreier, who wrote Hurting for Love about the condition.
"This woman fooled the media, she fooled the president's wife, she fooled the
Congress, and . . . many, many doctors."
Bush's case has a precedent. Yvonne Eldridge of Walnut
Creek, Calif., was honored by first lady Nancy Reagan for caring for 40 foster children.
She was later charged in the deaths of three youngsters in a Munchausen's
case. Her child abuse trial begins next month.
The cases pose a dilemma for lawyers. "Debate today
centers around whether the prosecution should even bring up the syndrome," says Ryan
Rainey, an assistant U.S. attorney in Washington, D.C. "It gives the jurors sympathy,
and an excuse to say, 'Well, this woman is sick.' "
Experts say more than 90% of offenders are mothers with
medical knowledge. Techniques can be monstrous. Some have blocked their children's air
passages with food. Children's food has been laced with laxatives to induce chronic
diarrhea.
"These are pretty cagey women," says Robin
Wilkinson, an Orlando prosecutor of a woman who poisoned her two children. One died.
"The nurses usually love them. They're there all the time, they're sleeping in the
child's room."
Joy Byers of the National Committee to Prevent Child
Abuse, says "The fact is, some parents, . . . are unwilling or unable to be loving
parents."
By Deborah Sharp, USA TODAY
|